Scotland has 47 thousand listed buildings – the majority allow Historic Scotland to intervene in repairs. And developers large and small, public and private are complaining about the extra cost, delay and obstruction the agency’s involvement appears to cause. Factor which could be pricing ordinary Scots out of restoring and inhabiting listed buildings.
Sisters Stephanie and Mandy Roxburgh, from Rothesay, bought a tenement to renovate and create 12 affordable flats. But when their bid to fit the highest quality uPVC windows was rejected by Historic Scotland, the sisters took their fight to Holyrood.
The agency’s preferred option -- 42 single glazed wooden sash and case windows -- was £100k more expensive than the uPVC option.
In Benbecula, Phil and Mairi Ladyman who run a heritage centre – the Nunton Steadings -- claim Historic Scotland’s insistence on authentic draughty, solid wooden doors without windows has created a hard-to-heat, unviable building they may have to leave.
And at Rowallan Castle near Kilmarnock, Niall Campbell a stonemason and civil engineer who helped restore Glasgow’s Rotundas has been told by Historic Scotland that he cannot refurbish a thirteenth century castle as the centrepiece of his £60m hotel and golf course.
Is conservation becoming preservation? Does the agency value authentic empty shells more than habitable buildings?
You can hear my investigation including Culture Minister Linda Fabiani, with live studio guest John Graham Historic Scotland’s Chief Executive -- 9am-10am Radio Scotland Monday August 4th. If you’ve comments email me here or call on the day 0500 92 95 00