This special edition of Riddoch Questions was recorded at Scotland’s Philanthropy Debate – a live event in Edinburgh, organised by the Scottish Community Foundation. In the week Chancellor Alastair Darling decides to give tax cuts – lower VAT and higher tax thresholds - the debate brings together several of the country’s wealthiest charitable donors to talk about giving, tax breaks, the credit crunch and how to spend money to maximum social benefit.
• Should charitable givers be able to attach strings to their cash?
• Is paying more tax a better way of redistributing the money of wealthy people?
• Are some donors funding projects the state ought to be paying for?
• Are there too many charities and how can smaller organisations compete with the big ones?
The panel includes Lord Robert Smith of Kelvin, chairman of the Weir Group and the 2014 Glasgow Commonwealth Games Organising Committee; Dame Stephanie Shirley, entrepreneur turned philanthropist, who’s given away £50 million in the past seven years; Sir Ian Wood, the founder of Britain’s biggest oil and gas services company, the Wood Group; Nick Ferguson, chairman of SVG Capital and the Institute for Philanthropy; and Anne Boyd, chair of the Scottish Community Foundation.
You can listen to the debate from 1.15-2pm – there will be no calls, emails or texts read out – but send your reactions to riddoch@bbc.co.uk as usual.